🛣️ GD Topic: What Is the Most Important Reason for Road Accidents in India?

R2R - GUIDING SSB ASPIRANTS LIKE AN ELDER SIBLING

R2R GD TOPIC NOTES

"Road safety is not just about following rules; it is about valuing human lives."

Increasing road accidents results in enormous loss of lives and livelihood. In your opinion, what is the most important reason for road accidents?

a. Inadequate Town Planning
b. Inefficient Law Enforcement
c. Powerful Motor Vehicles


India records one of the highest numbers of road accidents globally, with over 4.6 lakh accidents and nearly 1.55 lakh fatalities in 2022 (Ministry of Road Transport and Highways). While multiple factors contribute, let us examine how inadequate town planning, inefficient law enforcement, and powerful motor vehicles impact road safety.


1. Inadequate Town Planning - A Systemic Issue

- Poor urban infrastructure leads to congested roads, lack of pedestrian zones, and unscientific road designs, increasing the risk of accidents.
- Example: Over 40% of accidents in Indian cities occur at poorly designed intersections with confusing traffic flow.
- Road-to-vehicle ratio is critically low, causing congestion and reckless driving.
- Lack of proper lighting and poor road maintenance contribute to accidents, especially in rural and semi-urban areas.

Why is this a Major Cause?
✅ Faulty road design forces drivers to take unsafe turns, overspeed, and overtake dangerously.
✅ Absence of footpaths and pedestrian crossings increases risk for cyclists and walkers.
✅ Poor drainage and maintenance lead to waterlogging and potholes, causing loss of control.


2. Inefficient Law Enforcement - Weak Implementation of Rules

- Despite strict traffic laws, violations like overspeeding, drunk driving, and signal jumping are rampant.
- Example: In 2022, overspeeding caused 67% of total road fatalities, yet only a fraction of offenders are penalized effectively.
- Corruption within traffic police and lack of surveillance encourage bribery instead of penalties.
- Only 30% of drivers in India formally undergo driving tests, leading to a lack of road sense among motorists.

Why is this a Major Cause?
✅ Lax penalties allow repeat offenders to drive irresponsibly.
✅ Understaffed and undertrained traffic police cannot enforce regulations properly.
✅ Public awareness about traffic rules is low, leading to reckless driving behavior.


3. Powerful Motor Vehicles - Speeding Beyond Control

- The availability of high-speed vehicles at affordable prices has increased accidents, especially among young riders and inexperienced drivers.
- Example: India saw over 55,000 deaths in two-wheeler accidents in 2022, many involving high-performance bikes.
- Heavy commercial vehicles are often involved in accidents due to overloading and poor maintenance.
- Lack of speed-limit enforcement on expressways leads to high-impact collisions.

Why is this a Major Cause?
✅ High-powered vehicles enable reckless driving and overspeeding, leading to fatal crashes.
✅ Many drivers are not trained to handle high-speed cars and bikes safely.
✅ Lack of advanced braking and safety mechanisms in budget vehicles increases the risk of accidents.


Conclusion: What is the Biggest Reason? (Opinion*)

While all three factors contribute, inefficient law enforcement is the most crucial because:
- Even with poor town planning and fast vehicles, strict traffic laws can control reckless driving.
- Countries like Japan and Sweden have reduced road fatalities significantly by strictly enforcing penalties and using advanced surveillance systems.
- A strong law enforcement system ensures town planning is followed properly, and high-speed vehicles are regulated responsibly.

To reduce road accidents, India must strengthen traffic law enforcement, impose stricter penalties, and promote responsible driving behavior.

Sachin Jangir

AIR 128 - NDA 152

OUR COURSES View More